XVIII Military History Carnival
XVIII Military History Carnival
Ladies and gentlemen, old friends and new acquaintances, august peers: it is both a privilege and a pleasure to present this month’s Military History Carnival. For me – as the first time I’ve played host to one of these things – it’s been an informative and enjoyable experience; and it’s certainly opened my eyes to what the blogosphere has to offer. Besides this, it’s kept up the impression that I’m actually doing something, when in fact it’s all you lovely submitters out there who have done the work for me.
So, without further ado, to la Carnivale.
First of all we have the posts which I mentally compartmentalised as the ‘personal’ or ‘family’ section (being both male and a history student, categorising is inherent…). The first, and my favourite, is from the Trials of Penelope: in this post, Penelope talks about her family’s connection to the military from generation to generation. From the Family Travel Guide we have a travelogue describing a trip to Flanders’ fields, a moving and educational experience even for young children. The Intrepid Band has some great tips on how to trace ancestors or relatives who were wartime nurses. To round off this section, Philobiblon has this post discussing the lives of women whose main prospect, to get married, was shattered by the losses of the First World War.
It seems that October is a good month for anniversaries (it’s the anniversary of the battle of Edgehill, 1642, in three days – might have to rustle something up for that!), and we’ve got a fair few for the carnival. Gavin Robinson has commemorated breaking the Hindenburg Line, a World War I action that deserves more attention. A new blog in the ’sphere, Wacht Am Tyne, has got this post dedicated to the flight of the first British aircraft, and thinks about how things have changed since then, while Finding Dulcinea remembers the simply incredible bravery of Witold Pilecki, who allowed himself to be arrested in order to infiltrate Auschwitz. Lastly, there’s an experiment from Airminded in ‘Post-Blogging the Sudeten Crisis’: he’s posted newspaper articles, day-by-day, to give an idea of how the public might have seen it all unfold.
This paragraph is what you could call, if you wanted to, the more ‘standard’ military history, and it’s roughly arranged in order of period. So, furthest back, Gabrielle Campbell has a post about Hardenburg Castle, complete with stunning photos. Nick at Mercurius Politicus has been thinking on the violent response in Cirencester to the King’s attempt to raise troops at the start of the English Civil War. For that other well-known Civil War we’ve got a couple of submissions: Walking the Berkshires has this post about the careers of various ‘Free Men of Colour’, while Beatonna has a humorous tour of Gettysburg’s monuments, including pictures. From a similar timeframe, the Battlefield Biker has an interview with Mike Bunn and Clay Williams, authors of a new book on the Creek War of 1812. Lastly, and of the calibre we’ve come to expect from Alex Clark’s Military History and Warfare blog, there’s this post discussing the evolution of American ‘sky cavalry’: with a couple of pictures thrown in as well.
Despite all my valiant efforts, I couldn’t quite compartmentalise these posts, so they’re in the ‘Interesting Other’ section. An Armchair General’s Diary takes a look at the Babad Tanah Jawi, a piece of traditional Indonesian literature, and the way it deals with the invulnerability of heroes. Lastly is a post which I suppose should have been disqualified on grounds of tenuousness (it’s about rockets – the military have used rockets in history…) but I liked it so much that I thought I could sneak it in. It’s only small: take a quick look, I’ll leave it as a surprise.
Well, that appears to be everything. Thanks to everyone who sent in submissions, and apologies to those who I did disqualify: I promise that I tried not to be arbitrary! Details on the next Carnival are yet to be announced as a host for November is still needed. If you fancy the job, get on over to Investigations of a Dog and get in touch with Gavin, our dear organiser.
October 20, 2008 at 8:00 am
[...] The October Military History Carnival is now up at Chronologi Cogitationes. [...]
October 20, 2008 at 8:07 am
Thanks for doing this. It’s looking really good.
October 20, 2008 at 12:48 pm
A great edition – thanks for the mention! (And great blog as well, I only discovered it last week).
October 20, 2008 at 1:30 pm
Cheers. Coming from the Master, that means a lot!
October 20, 2008 at 2:16 pm
[...] XVIII Military History Carnival is up at Chronologi Cogitationes. This month I’m picking a post from a new blog, Wacht Am Tyne, on the centenary of the first flight (powered, controlled, heavier-than-air) in Britain, which was achieved by Samuel Franklin Cody on 16 October 1908. (I had a photo of British Army Aeroplane No. 1a in an earlier post.) Three reasons: firstly, because I was going to write about this myself but completely forgot; secondly, because it’s an interesting post even though (or because) it’s not at all the one I would have written; thirdly because, according to the blog’s About page, it’s intended for: anyone who enjoys reading about military history, has ever gone to the IWM on their own, or has ever re-enacted the Battle of Waterloo using condiment packets and empty glasses at their local [...]
October 20, 2008 at 5:02 pm
Please to see my blog (nikotev.wordpress.com) for military historyq military policy and diplomacy!
With best wishes Nikolay Kotev (Bulgaria)
October 20, 2008 at 9:12 pm
Nice work….a goodly selection
October 21, 2008 at 2:45 pm
The Babad Tanah Jawi is Indonesian, not Indian…
(I know it can be tricky to separate the two because the Indian cultures have greatly influenced Indonesian ones in the past–in particular, the Javanese (the subject of the Babad) still show some remnants of that influence in its language and rituals down to this day.)
October 21, 2008 at 2:54 pm
My apologies, I honestly don’t know if that was a mistake or a typo…
October 22, 2008 at 4:40 am
No problem. It’s a very natural and very forgivable mistake, at least as long as the person writing doesn’t have Southeast Asian history as his primary specialty. (It should also be an easily rectified one, I suppose?)
October 22, 2008 at 8:03 am
You’re quite right. All done. I think I can explain it by the theory that the more I read as part of my Masters, the less I have room in my head for other things. Such as motor functions.
October 22, 2008 at 11:45 pm
[...] after you’ve done that, you might also want to check out the Military History Carnival – about much more than tin soldiers, I promise, and the recent Britblog Roundup on Redemption [...]
November 4, 2008 at 4:51 am
[...] carnivals that have featured my posts recently: the Carnival of Children’s Literature, the Military History Carnival and the Carnival of Family Life. Tags: advice, blog carnival, blogs, family travel, Great Travel [...]
April 4, 2009 at 6:09 pm
Dear Friend!
the topics for American foreign policy (“UNO, USSR and Cuwait Crisis”, “The USA on the road…” and etc.)
Welcome to my “Blog”, with electronic adress URL: http://nikotev.wordpress.com/ . The name of the blog is “History and I”
The Blog is for SOE, OSS activity on the Balkans during the WWII, some problems of the modern wars in the end of XX Century, American Foreign policy and etc.
The news:
In the “Pages” there are many new photos in:
1) 700 photos from the period of the WWII
2) 100 photos from the period of the WWI
3) 150 US, british and USSR`s posters from the period of WWII
4) 30 Axis posters from the period of the WWII
5) 30 pictures from the period of WWII
6) All topics for british commandos on the Balkans
7) the topics for modern latinoamerican guerrilla (about “Tupamaros”)
9) the modern photos from the war against talibans in Afghanistan (in all topics for Soviet-Afghanian War).
The Blog in this moment is 4-th in english “Top Military Net”, 5-th in Spanish “Mundo en Guerra”, 2-nd in german “Military toplist”, 8-th in American “100 Top Military photos”, 49-th in Russian “Военноисторические ресурсы” еnd etc.
Your friend Nikolay Kotev